Hello David,
though it is an interesting approach, I'm against it for the following reasons:
- If we use a core dump, this guarantees (in a way) that only people from the community would look at the code. I mean, we can even register who downloaded the code. Therefore you can assume that the chance of getting something out of your code which is returned to the toolkit is higher.
- IMHO it is easier to convince clients that they should give the code back to the community of OpenACS instead of all the people around the world, who just happen to come to your page.
- I try to imagine Greenpeace doing this. Within a month they will probably have 200 bids for improving their website from random strikers all around the world trying to get their hands on some money.
That said, if we get this as a package, yeah why not. Just because I wouldn't do it does not mean everyone should be opposed to it and it is always better to have the choice. If you have a strong feeling about it, you might as well make a community bid. After all, it is not that much work 😊.
