Forum OpenACS Improvement Proposals (TIPs): TIP #107 IMPLEMENTED: Get rid of version info in catalog xml files

Request notifications

1. They're not used
2. Sometimes they're not updated, the version in the xml file is different than the version in the package info xml file
3. Nothing else in a package has its own version info, version is provided by the package, not each file

and most important:

4. IT MAKES MERGING HARDER because if someone does update the catalog version files, you get merge conflicts on each and every one.

Collapse
Posted by Avni Khatri on
All 4 points make sense.
I can vouch for #4. Ran into conflicts in the catalog files a lot during zen.
Collapse
Posted by Lee Denison on
I vote yes.
approve
Approve
approve
Collapse
Posted by Dave Bauer on
approve
approve, although the real problem for merging is that we have no real merging technology at all using cvs.
Marked as "Approved"
Better late than never