Forum OpenACS Development: Re: forms as columns of template::list

Collapse
6: Re: forms as columns of template::list (response to 5)
Posted by Emmanuelle Raffenne on 12/16/08 12:14 PM
Dave, Luis,

From the accessibility point of view, having one form with a form element in each row is not a good solution.

Collapse
7: Re: Res: Re: forms as columns of template::list (response to 6)
Posted by Luis de la Fuente on 12/16/08 12:49 PM
Emma, I agree, this is not a good solution. Maybe it looks better if we don't take into account the accesibility. But if we do...

I will reconsider the user interface.

Thank you for your comments.

Collapse
8: Re: Res: Re: forms as columns of template::list (response to 7)
Posted by Ryan Gallimore on 12/18/08 01:52 PM
Hi Luis,

If forms within a table cause an accessibility problem, perhaps you can write your own template for the list using divs.

Create a new adp file in /packages/acs-templating/resources/lists/ and reference it in

<listtemplate name="mylist" style="newlisttemplatefile"></listtemplate>

You can look at list.adp in the directory above for an example. Play with the CSS at /packages/acs-templating/www/resources/lists.css

Good luck,
Ryan

Collapse
9: Re: Res: Re: forms as columns of template::list (response to 8)
Posted by Emmanuelle Raffenne on 12/19/08 02:51 PM
Hi Ryan,

I'm afraid that marking up the data with DIV won't solve the accessibility problem. Actually, it would introduce another one. Tabular data has to be marked up using the TABLE element and the corresponding TH/TD and their attributes to associate header cells with data cells.

This is documented in WCAG 1.0 (checkpoint 5.1 and 5.2 - priority 1) and in WCAG 2.0 (technique H51 for success criterion 1.3.1 - level A).

Collapse
10: Re: Res: Re: forms as columns of template::list (response to 9)
Posted by Ryan Gallimore on 12/20/08 12:36 AM
Hi Emmanuelle,

Would it be possible, then, to accomplish accessible markup using a custom template, as I suggested above?

Collapse
11: Re: Res: Re: forms as columns of template::list (response to 10)
Posted by Emmanuelle Raffenne on 12/20/08 01:35 PM
Valid markup is not a guarantee of accessibility by itself, although it's part of it. Using appropriate markup is even more important. HTML is primarily used to structure the content semantically (not to format it), so each type of data has to be marked up according to its nature.

In this case, the problem is not the template. The default template for template::list produces valid and appropriate markup for tabular data. Using a table to format a form is acceptable from the accessibility perspective (as long as a few rules are followed), but not recommended. The problem here would be to mix the two types of content: the data and the form to modify it.